#24A
21st Century
Founded 1958
AutoHomeRenters
Farmers subsidiary with online focus.
(877) 310-2021
Market Share: 0.2%
Visit Website#99A
AAA Insurance
Founded 1902
AutoHomeLife
Regional AAA clubs offering insurance.
Varies by region
Market Share: 0.5%
Visit Website#46A++
ACE/Chubb
Founded 1985
BusinessCommercialSpecialty
Global commercial insurance leader.
(800) 252-4670
Market Share: 0.7%
Visit WebsiteAutoHomeBusiness
Midwest regional with excellent service.
(800) 242-7666
Market Share: 0.4%
Visit WebsiteBusinessCommercialSpecialty
International commercial and specialty insurer.
(877) 638-4244
Market Share: 0.8%
Visit WebsiteAutoHomeLife+1 more
Large agent network with Drivewise rewards program.
(877) 810-2920
Market Share: 9.2%
Visit Website#10A
American Family
Founded 1927
AutoHomeRenters+2 more
Regional carrier with strong Midwest presence and KnowYourDrive program.
(800) 692-6326
Market Share: 2.8%
Visit Website#39A
American Modern
Founded 1965
Manufactured HomeSpecialtyLandlord
Specialty property insurance leader.
(800) 543-2644
Market Share: 0.1%
Visit Website#15A++
Amica Mutual
Founded 1907
AutoHomeLife
Oldest mutual auto insurer with top customer service ratings.
(800) 242-6422
Market Share: 0.6%
Visit WebsiteBusinessWorkers CompSpecialty
Small business and workers comp focus.
(877) 528-7878
Market Share: 0.4%
Visit Website#66
Answer Financial
Founded 2000
AutoHomeComparison
Insurance comparison marketplace.
Visit Website#83A-
Assurant
Founded 1892
SpecialtyRentersMobile
Specialty insurance and extended warranties.
(888) 260-7736
Market Share: 0.2%
Visit Website#14A++
Auto-Owners Insurance
Founded 1916
AutoHomeBusiness+1 more
Regional carrier with strong financial ratings and agent network.
(888) 252-4626
Market Share: 1.5%
Visit Website#47A++
Berkshire Hathaway GUARD
Founded 1971
BusinessWorkers CompCommercial
Workers compensation and commercial specialist.
(877) 288-4273
Market Share: 0.3%
Visit WebsiteBoatMarineSpecialty
Leading boat insurance specialist.
(800) 283-2883
Market Share: 0.1%
Visit Website#28A-
Branch Insurance
Founded 2017
AutoHome
Bundled coverage with group discounts.
(833) 272-6241
Market Share: 0.03%
Visit Website#36B+
Bristol West
Founded 1966
AutoSR-22
Farmers subsidiary for non-standard auto.
(800) 274-7865
Market Share: 0.1%
Visit WebsiteHomeAutoBusiness+1 more
High-value home and specialty insurance for affluent clients.
(800) 252-4670
Market Share: 1.9%
Visit Website#51A+
Cincinnati Insurance
Founded 1950
AutoHomeBusiness
Regional carrier with strong agent relationships.
(877) 942-4246
Market Share: 0.6%
Visit Website#86
Citizens Property Insurance
Founded 2002
HomeCoastal
Florida state-backed insurer of last resort.
(866) 411-2742
Market Share: 0.3%
Visit Website#25A-
Clearcover
Founded 2016
Auto
Digital-only auto insurer with transparent pricing.
(855) 444-1875
Market Share: 0.05%
Visit WebsiteBusinessProfessional LiabilitySpecialty
Commercial insurance leader with deep expertise.
(877) 262-2727
Market Share: 1.2%
Visit Website#67
Compare.com
Founded 2009
AutoHomeComparison
Multi-carrier comparison platform.
Visit Website#50A-
Coterie Insurance
Founded 2018
BusinessGeneral Liability
Instant small business insurance quotes.
(855) 926-8374
Market Share: 0.01%
Visit Website#57A
Country Financial
Founded 1925
AutoHomeLife+1 more
Farm Bureau affiliated insurer.
(866) 268-6879
Market Share: 0.3%
Visit Website#98A
CSAA Insurance
Founded 1914
AutoHomeLife
Regional AAA clubs offering insurance.
Varies by region
Market Share: 0.5%
Visit Website#35B+
Dairyland
Founded 1953
AutoMotorcycleSR-22
Travelers subsidiary for non-standard risks.
(800) 334-0090
Market Share: 0.2%
Visit Website#32B+
Direct Auto
Founded 1991
AutoSR-22
Affordable coverage for high-risk drivers.
(877) 463-4732
Market Share: 0.2%
Visit Website#60A-
Donegal Insurance
Founded 1889
AutoHomeBusiness
Mid-Atlantic regional carrier.
(800) 877-0600
Market Share: 0.1%
Visit Website#79A
EMC Insurance
Founded 1911
BusinessAutoHome
Regional carrier with strong reputation.
(800) 447-2295
Market Share: 0.1%
Visit Website#65A+
Encompass
Founded 2000
AutoHome
Allstate subsidiary with independent agents.
(800) 262-5950
Market Share: 0.2%
Visit Website#13A+
Erie Insurance
Founded 1925
AutoHomeBusiness+1 more
Regional carrier with excellent customer satisfaction ratings.
(800) 458-0811
Market Share: 1.7%
Visit Website#23A+
Esurance
Founded 1999
AutoHomeRenters+1 more
Allstate subsidiary with digital-first approach.
(800) 378-7262
Market Share: 0.3%
Visit Website#58A
Farm Bureau Insurance
Founded 1949
AutoHomeFarm
State-based farm and rural insurance.
Varies by state
Market Share: 0.5%
Visit Website#7A
Farmers Insurance
Founded 1928
AutoHomeLife+1 more
Comprehensive coverage with local agent support.
(888) 327-6335
Market Share: 4.2%
Visit Website#90A+
Federated Insurance
Founded 1904
BusinessCommercial
Business insurance with risk management.
(800) 533-0472
Market Share: 0.1%
Visit WebsiteMobile HomeSpecialtyRV
Farmers subsidiary for specialty properties.
(800) 527-3907
Market Share: 0.1%
Visit Website#95A
Frankenmuth Insurance
Founded 1868
AutoHomeBusiness
Michigan mutual with excellent service.
(800) 234-3000
Market Share: 0.1%
Visit WebsiteAutoHomeRenters+1 more
Direct-to-consumer leader with competitive rates
(800) 861-8380
Market Share: 13.8%
Visit Website#53A
Grange Insurance
Founded 1935
AutoHomeBusiness+1 more
Mutual insurer serving 13 states.
(800) 445-3030
Market Share: 0.3%
Visit Website#77A
Great American
Founded 1872
BusinessSpecialtySurety
Specialty commercial insurance provider.
(800) 543-2644
Market Share: 0.3%
Visit WebsiteClassic CarAntiqueSpecialty
Agreed value coverage for classic vehicles.
(866) 338-4006
Market Share: 0.05%
Visit WebsiteClassic CarCollectorSpecialty
World leader in classic and collector car insurance.
(877) 922-9701
Market Share: 0.1%
Visit Website#20A
Hanover Insurance
Founded 1852
AutoHomeBusiness+1 more
Strong business insurance focus with personal lines.
(800) 628-0250
Market Share: 0.4%
Visit Website#94A
Hastings Mutual
Founded 1885
AutoHomeBusiness
Michigan-based mutual carrier.
(800) 442-8277
Market Share: 0.1%
Visit WebsiteHomeRenters
Smart home insurance with proactive protection.
(844) 426-7006
Market Share: 0.05%
Visit WebsiteBusinessProfessional LiabilityCyber
Small business and professional liability specialist.
(888) 472-7424
Market Share: 0.1%
Visit Website#100A
Horace Mann
Founded 1945
AutoHomeLife
Insurance for educators and school employees.
(800) 999-1030
Market Share: 0.1%
Visit Website#55A
IMT Insurance
Founded 1884
AutoHomeFarm
Iowa-based farm and personal lines specialist.
(800) 274-3531
Market Share: 0.2%
Visit Website#34B+
Infinity Insurance
Founded 1955
AutoSR-22
Non-standard auto with flexible payment plans.
(800) 334-1661
Market Share: 0.2%
Visit Website#74A
K&K Insurance
Founded 1952
EventSportsSpecialty
Event and sports insurance specialist.
(800) 426-2889
Market Share: 0.05%
Visit WebsiteAutoHomeLife+1 more
Affordable coverage with flexible payment options.
(866) 536-7376
Market Share: 0.6%
Visit Website#27A-
Kin Insurance
Founded 2016
Home
Coastal home insurance specialist.
(855) 546-0129
Market Share: 0.04%
Visit WebsiteRentersHomeAuto+1 more
AI-powered digital insurance with instant quotes and claims.
(844) 733-8666
Market Share: 0.1%
Visit Website#6A
Liberty Mutual
Founded 1912
AutoHomeBusiness+1 more
Global insurer with customizable coverage options.
(800) 290-7933
Market Share: 5.8%
Visit Website#88
Louisiana Citizens
Founded 2003
HomeCoastal
Louisiana state-backed property insurer.
(877) 455-2487
Market Share: 0.05%
Visit WebsiteAutoHomeBusiness
Spanish multinational with US presence.
(888) 627-3731
Market Share: 0.2%
Visit WebsiteSpecialtyProfessional LiabilityEquine
Specialty insurance and reinsurance.
(800) 431-1270
Market Share: 0.2%
Visit Website#97A
Meemic Insurance
Founded 1950
AutoHome
Educators-focused insurance.
(800) 283-6642
Market Share: 0.05%
Visit Website#19A
Mercury Insurance
Founded 1962
AutoHomeRenters+1 more
California-based carrier with competitive rates.
(800) 503-3724
Market Share: 0.5%
Visit WebsiteAutoHomeLife
Strong life insurance offerings with property and casualty options.
(800) 638-5433
Market Share: 1.2%
Visit Website#30A-
Metromile
Founded 2011
Auto
Pay-per-mile auto insurance for low-mileage drivers.
(888) 242-5204
Market Share: 0.02%
Visit Website#96A-
Michigan Mutual
Founded 1912
AutoHome
Michigan-only mutual insurer.
(800) 835-4552
Market Share: 0.05%
Visit Website#93A
Motorists Insurance
Founded 1928
AutoHomeBusiness
Ohio-based mutual insurer.
(800) 227-2757
Market Share: 0.1%
Visit Website#64A-
National General
Founded 1939
AutoHomeRenters+1 more
Allstate subsidiary with diverse products.
(888) 293-5108
Market Share: 0.3%
Visit Website#8A+
Nationwide
Founded 1926
AutoHomeBusiness+1 more
Fortune 100 company with vanishing deductible program.
(877) 669-6877
Market Share: 3.9%
Visit Website#41A-
Next Insurance
Founded 2016
BusinessGeneral LiabilityProfessional Liability
Digital small business insurance platform.
(888) 550-6398
Market Share: 0.05%
Visit Website#87
North Carolina JUA
Founded 1969
HomeCoastal
NC coastal property insurance pool.
(919) 783-9790
Market Share: 0.05%
Visit Website#89
North Carolina JUA
Founded 1969
HomeCoastal
NC coastal property insurance pool.
(919) 783-9790
Market Share: 0.02%
Visit Website#92A
Pekin Insurance
Founded 1921
AutoHomeBusiness
Michigan mutual with excellent service.
(800) 322-0160
Market Share: 0.1%
Visit Website#61A-
Penn National
Founded 1919
AutoHomeBusiness
Pennsylvania-based regional carrier.
(800) 688-7366
Market Share: 0.1%
Visit Website#76A++
Philadelphia Insurance
Founded 1962
BusinessProfessional LiabilitySpecialty
Commercial specialty insurance leader.
(800) 873-4552
Market Share: 0.2%
Visit Website#49A-
Pie Insurance
Founded 2017
Workers Comp
Digital workers compensation insurance.
(855) 743-4678
Market Share: 0.02%
Visit Website#62A-
Plymouth Rock
Founded 1982
AutoHome
Northeast regional with competitive rates.
(855) 993-4470
Market Share: 0.2%
Visit Website#68
Policygenius
Founded 2014
LifeHomeAuto+1 more
Digital insurance marketplace and advisor.
Visit Website#3A+
Progressive
Founded 1937
AutoHomeRV+2 more
Innovation leader with usage-based insurance options
(800) 776-4737
Market Share: 11.7%
Visit Website#72A+
Progressive Marine
Founded 1937
BoatYachtMarine
Comprehensive marine insurance coverage.
(800) 776-4737
Market Share: 0.2%
Visit WebsiteBusinessSpecialtyProfessional Liability
International specialty insurer.
(800) 367-1000
Market Share: 0.2%
Visit WebsiteSpecialtySuretyProfessional Liability
Specialty insurance and surety bonds.
(800) 331-4931
Market Share: 0.1%
Visit Website#22A-
Root Insurance
Founded 2015
AutoRenters
App-based insurance with rates based on driving behavior.
(866) 980-9431
Market Share: 0.1%
Visit Website#33B+
Safe Auto
Founded 1993
AutoSR-22
State minimum coverage specialist.
(800) 723-3288
Market Share: 0.2%
Visit WebsiteAutoHomeRenters+1 more
Liberty Mutual subsidiary with RightTrack usage-based program.
(800) 332-3226
Market Share: 0.8%
Visit Website#78A+
Selective Insurance
Founded 1926
BusinessAutoHome
Regional commercial and personal lines.
(973) 948-3000
Market Share: 0.2%
Visit Website#91A+
Sentry Insurance
Founded 1904
BusinessAutoHome
Mutual insurer with business focus.
(800) 473-6879
Market Share: 0.2%
Visit Website#56A
Shelter Insurance
Founded 1946
AutoHomeLife
Midwest mutual with competitive rates.
(800) 743-5837
Market Share: 0.3%
Visit WebsiteBusinessSpecialtyCommercial
Global commercial insurance provider.
(800) 282-1446
Market Share: 0.1%
Visit Website#59A
State Auto
Founded 1921
AutoHomeBusiness
Regional carrier in 33 states.
(888) 782-8326
Market Share: 0.2%
Visit Website#1A++
State Farm
Founded 1922
AutoHomeLife+1 more
Largest auto insurer in the US with extensive agent network
(800) 782-8332
Market Share: 16.4%
Visit Website#84A-
Stillwater Insurance
Founded 2000
HomeCoastalSpecialty
Coastal property insurance specialist.
(866) 210-2009
Market Share: 0.1%
Visit Website#31B+
The General
Founded 1963
AutoSR-22
Non-standard auto insurance specialist.
(800) 280-1466
Market Share: 0.3%
Visit Website#11A+
The Hartford
Founded 1810
AutoHomeBusiness+1 more
AARP partnership for 50+ drivers. Strong business insurance.
(888) 546-9099
Market Share: 2.1%
Visit WebsiteAutoHomeComparison
Insurance comparison and research platform.
Visit WebsiteAuto
Flexible auto insurance you can pause.
(844) 864-4531
Market Share: 0.02%
Visit Website#81A+
Tokio Marine
Founded 1879
BusinessSpecialtyMarine
Japanese multinational with US operations.
(877) 455-1212
Market Share: 0.1%
Visit Website#9A++
Travelers
Founded 1853
AutoHomeBusiness+1 more
Oldest continuously operating insurer in America.
(800) 842-5075
Market Share: 3.4%
Visit Website#85B+
Universal Property
Founded 2004
HomeCoastalSpecialty
Florida-focused property insurer.
(800) 861-2628
Market Share: 0.1%
Visit WebsiteAutoHomeLife+1 more
Exclusively for military members and families. Top-rated customer service.
(800) 531-8722
Market Share: 6.1%
Visit Website#54A
West Bend Mutual
Founded 1894
AutoHomeBusiness
Wisconsin-based mutual with strong reputation.
(866) 922-6329
Market Share: 0.2%
Visit WebsiteBusinessCommercialSpecialty
Global commercial insurance powerhouse.
(800) 987-3373
Market Share: 0.9%
Visit Website